In order to avoid any confusion, we decided to stick to a kind of value table when rating a review; from 0 to 10, here's what each mark is supposed to mean (half points will be used to temper such or such element in the music and give more fluidity to the reviewer's final judgement).


0: nothing to save
1: extremely bad
2: very bad with some sparse interesting features
3: bad with a few good ideas
4: bad but there's potential for more
5: listenable but mediocre
6: average but there's potential for more
7: good
8: very good
9: excellent
10: outstanding in every aspect

Thanks for clarifying! :-)